Tuesday, 17 July 2012

The Bakonjo, Bamba clashes: Looking beyond the fights


By Felix Basiime, Thembo Kahungu Misairi & Geoffrey Mutegeki Araali


PHOTO: Some of the Bakonjo who were displaced by the clashes camp at Buhindu Primary School in Bundibugyo District. The clashes that ensued over erection of a shrine by King Mumbere led to destruction of property and displacement. Government has since deployed in the area to avoid any further clashes. PHOTO BY GEOFFREY MUTEGEKI ARAALI 



Posted Saturday, July 14 2012 at 01:27 (http://www.monitor.co.ug/News/National/The+Bakonjo++Bamba+clashes++++Looking+beyond+the+fights/-/688334/1453512/-/view/printVersion/-/nunkgk/-/index.html)

In Summary

Early indicators? During celebrations to mark the Rwenzururu anniversary on June 30, a live broadcast of the King’s programme was switched off on a government-owned FM radio station. The move, although engineers said was a technical fault, was viewed by most critics as intentional.

When government recognised the Obusinga Bwa Rwenzururu Kingdom in October 2009 in Kasese District, it inadvertently also sowed unforeseen seeds of anarchy.

The recognition came after more than 20 years of stiff persuasion and cajoling, however, the kingdom today could end up in split even further than it was five years ago along the various ethnic groups that it consists of in Kasese and Bundibugyo districts.

Today, the kingdom is besieged with mind boggling conflicts to its north, west and south borders. Two weeks ago, the minority Basongora ethnic group in Kasese District crowned their own king setting a new chapter of conflict against King Charles Mumbere after land issues that divided the kingdom for so long.

This time though, another ethnic conflict has reared its head in neighbouring Bundibugyo between the between the Bamba-Babwisi – the king’s subjects and the Bakonzo – the king’s own tribe.

The two conflicts are different in that the conflict in Kasese is about Basongora creating their own kingdom while in Bundibugyo, the majority Bamba do not want the Obusinga Bwa Rwenzururu to use their territory and name as part of the kingdom.

The current conflict in Bundibugyo was sparked off after King Charles Mumbere visited the area on June 30 and among others set up a shrine at his father’s home area in Kirindi, Busaru, Bwamba County.

The Bamba felt that Mumbere’s actions of establishing a shrine and raising the Obusinga Bwa Rwenzururu flag in their area tantamounts to conquering their territory.

Ms Jane Alisemera, the former Woman MP Bundibugyo, who in 2009 led a team of Bamba elders to meet President Museveni before government recognised Obusinga Bwa Rwenzururu, says: “We agreed that the word ‘Bamba’ be excluded in the Obusinga issues.

“When the Bamba succeeded from seceding from Tooro Kingdom and later got their own district, they somehow relaxed and Obusinga kept on using their name in their dealings until of late when the Bamba have said no,” she adds.

The Bamba argue that in 1962, they participated together with the Bakonzo in the Rwenzururu Movement to secede from the Tooro Kingdom which they both said was oppressing them.

On June 30, 1962, Isaya Mukirania (a Mukonzo and father to King Mumbere), Mr Peter Mupalya and Mr Yeremia Kawamala both Bamba representatives in the Tooro Kingdom walked out of the Orukurato (Tooro Kingdom Parliament) allegedly over issues of lack of equality.

The Bamba today argue that after that purpose was achieved, they abandoned the Movement but that Mumbere’s father - Mukirania - instead pursued another personal agenda of creating a kingdom out of the movement which the Bamba say they have never been part and parcel.

However, grievances between the ethnic groups were silent until July 6 when they clashed in Bundibugyo. The Bamba moved to torch Mumbere’s shrine, one person died in the melee, and several others were injured, property destroyed and hundreds, mainly Bakonjo, were displaced.

Government officials, Information and Communication Technology Minister Dr Ruhakana Rugunda and the Inspector General of Police visited Bundibugyo and Kasese districts to try to restore peace this week.

Political talk
During celebrations to mark the Rwenzururu anniversary on June 30, a live broadcast of the king’s programme was switched off on a government-owned FM radio station.

The Rwenzururu Kingdom spokesperson, Mr David Bradford Nguru, said: “That was the worst experience we have had in Bundibugyo as the radio was switched off under unknown circumstances midway the function. And everyone thinks it was intended although engineers said it was a technical problem.”

Some elders in both Bundibugyo and Kasese believe that the current conflict in Bundibugyo is politically motivated.

“Some of the things are politically motivated” says Ms Alisemera. She adds: “Some people have selfish motives, this issue is simple to stem off, it is a matter of dialogue, I call upon the President to come quickly to solve this.”

Chief Prince of the Rwenzururu Kingdom, Mr Christopher Kibanzanga, says: “There is something deeper in the Bundibugyo conflict than meets the eye. Therefore we must also go deeper and investigate it because the Bamba and Bakonzo have lived together and intermarried for long without any problem.”

He adds: “There is survival politics, when some politicians can’t provide roads and other services, they resort to tribal conflicts.”

An elder in Bundibugyo, who preferred not to be named for fear of persecution, believes that there is politics in the matter, adding that there are people who want to develop a political clout by mobilising clashes in the area.

Many are accusing Bundibugyo Woman MP Harriet Ntabazi as among those mobilising the Bamba to oppose the Rwenzururu Kingdom presence in the district.

“It’s the woman MP and her followers that are bringing about all this confusion in order to gain political popularity for her people,” an elder said.

The same sources say Ntabazi and her brother, Swizin Kyomuhendo, a lecturer at Makerere
University are plotting to override State minister Kamanda Bataringaya as MP for Bwamba County in the 2016 polls because Kamanda, although a Mwamba, allegedly has a soft heart for King Mumbere.

There are some Bamba in Bundibugyo who pay allegiance to King Mumbere.

It is also alleged that the same camp is fronting one Mr Gafabusa to take over from the district chairperson, Mr Jolly Tibimanya, whom they accuse of betraying the Bamba community by welcoming Mumbere in the district for the 50th anniversary of the Rwenzururu Kingdom on June 30.

“These people want to create anything that can excite the Bamba community so that they gain political popularity in the build-up to the 2016 general elections. But that’s not how politicians build their profile,” the elder reasoned.

But Ntabazi, who also confirms that there is political motivation behind the Bamba-Bakonjo clashes, denies any involvement. “I partly believe there is politics in this confusion, although the Obusinga is not a political organisation but people are having different minds here in Bundibugyo. To me, the fight has something hidden in it and I am not a ring leader as people claim,” Ntabazi says.

Oil factor
Ntabazi, a Mwamba herself who is married to a Mukonzo with five children, says the Bamba are not fighting for a kingdom.

According to her, the Bamba feel that the 1962 walk-out from Tooro Kingdom was not aimed at creating another cultural institution but to come out of oppression.

The legislator believes that the confusion among the Bakonjo and Bamba is fuelled by former political contestants who failed in the 2011 elections.

“All these fellows want to gain cheap grounds in disguise,” Ntabazi says, adding: “Actually this problem is all about politics of the area because there is no one claiming to be a king in Bundibugyo.”

Some officials in the Rwenzururu Kingdom believe that the new conflict in Kasese and Bundibugyo is a reflection of the changing economic fortunes of the kingdom occasioned by the rich natural resources in the region.

Rwenzori region is being earmarked for oil and gas as exploration already going on in Ntoroko District and more studies being carried out in the Queen Elizabeth National Park in Kasese District.

The Rwenzururu Kingdom officials suspect that there might be links between the Bamba, Basongora and other minority tribes to take control of the Rwenzori region in quest to take a great benefit of the economic potentials.

“It is likely that these tribes may be building a liaison aimed at capturing the area on the flat lands and push the Bakonzo up hills hence taking over control of the resources. But this is unacceptable and it cannot happen” a kingdom official says.

The UPDF Second Division Commander, Brig. Patrick Kankiriho, says the tribal clashes in Bundibugyo are not acceptable because they contribute to insecurity in the district that borders the Democratic Republic of Congo.

“The people of Rwenzururu Kingdom should solve their problems amicably because any fighting contributes to insecurity. But such fights cannot be a chance for the enemy to recruit because what motivation do they have for someone who is fighting for cultural benefits?” Brig.Kankiriho asks.

Need to reconcile
Mr Peter Kamba Mupalya, 87, the only living member of the founding team of the Rwenzururu movement that successfully seceded from Tooro kingdom says: “We started the Rwenzururu

Movement to secede from Tooro in 1962 after they denied us the position of premiership to rotate among them and us.”

“Last year, I was asked by King Mumbere to work as an ambassador for Rwenzururu to create a new relationship with Tooro and other areas. I am coordinating activities of people within the region to work on repairing relationships,” Mupalya says.

He adds: “For example I am an elder in Tooro Kingdom Elders Forum and I love the King of Tooro, we are looking forward to seeing people in the region reconcile because now we want unity and peace.”

Mupalya says the establishment of the shrine should not embroil the residents into clashes for they (Bamba) are not forced to pay allegiance to the king of Rwenzururu.

He adds: “The king (Mumbere) hails from here, Bwamba County, his father Mukirane was born here. I don’t see the reason why this should raise dust. He is free to do anything on his land. My argument is that let those who support Obusinga do it and those who don’t should not disturb peace.”

He urged the Bamba-Babwisi Elders Development Association members to use the right procedures not through fighting and inciting others.

“They should let the king (Mumbere) visit his subjects in Bwamba, even the other Kings (Oyo) can come and visit Bundibugyo,” Mupalya reasons.

“This conflict (in Bundibugyo) cannot be won by Bakonzo or Bamba because we are so intermarried, we need Africans not ethnicity,” says.

Christopher Kibazanga, adding, “We (sons and daughters from Kasese and Bundibugyo both Bakonzo and Bamba living in Kampala) are sending a team to the area to investigate the conflict and come up with solutions”

Although President Museveni is expected to meet the conflicting parties in Rwenzori any time, the conflicts in Bundibugyo and Kasese if mishandled or neglected or handled late, can result in severe clashes.

“Government has nurtured ethnicity especially in Kasese District and will pay dearly for it. How can they for a example issue land at 3:1 ratio between minority Basongora and majority Bakonzo respectively?” Kibazanga asks.

He adds: “The Bakonzo struggled for over 20 years to recognise their kingdom while the Basongora got it on a silver plate.” However, Mr Jimmy Kagoro Muzoora, the Spokesperson of the Busongora King, thinks the reconciliation move may be dented with flesh moves like taking away their royal drum and flag on Wednesday at Muhokya.

“Such dirty moves dent the reconciliatory programme in which the president was asked by Mumbere to meet a delegation of the Bakonzo, Basongora and Bamba,” he says.

=================================================
About the Bakonjo and Bamba
In the early 20th century, the Bakonjo and Bamba tribes were integrated into the Tooro Kingdom as a political manoeuvre by the British colonialists: the neighbouring Bunyoro monarchy was anti-colonialist and rose up in arms in what was known as the Nyangire rebellion.

The British wished to strengthen the pro-British Tooro Kingdom then.
The Bakonjo and Bamba initially accepted being arbitrarily made subjects of the Tooro monarch but asked the Uganda Protectorate to provide them with their own district in the 1950s, separate from Tooro District.
They successfully seceded from Tooro Kingdom on June 30, 1962.
After a long struggle that was affected by different mind sets, including the pro-Obusinga and anti-Obusinga, government of President Museveni finally recognised the Rwenzururu Kingdom on October 19, 2009.

The Rwenzururu Kingdom claims to be stretching to the Eastern DR Congo with a big delegation always crossing borders for the cultural functions every year.


Basongora-Bakonzo wrangle: A looming tribal bloodbath?


By Felix Basiime, Enid Ninsiima & Thembo Kahungu



PHOTOS: Basongora cultural leader, Rwigi IV Kabumba Rutakirwa Ivan Bwebale and Rwenzururu King, Charles Wesley Mumbere. Photos by Thembo Kahungu & Felix Basiime

Posted Saturday, July 7 2012 at 01:00 (http://www.monitor.co.ug/News/National/Basongora+Bakonzo+wrangle++A+looming+tribal+bloodbath+/-/688334/1446554/-/item/2/-/idwhvfz/-/index.html)

In Summary
Cultural impasse. Whereas the Basongora say pupils studying from schools in their area should stop singing the Obusinga anthem and traditional dance, the King of Rwenzururu insists he does not recognise Busongora Kingdom and pupils should continue singing and dancing to the royal anthem.

When the High Court in Fort Portal on May 7 ruled in favour of 289 farmers who in 2006 sued government for giving their land to pastoralists, it looked like the old conflict between the parties (Bakonzo and Basongora) would die.

The assumption was wrong as no one knew that the next wrangle would be over separation of royal and administrative powers. Court ruled in favour of the cultivators (mainly Bakonzo) and ordered immediate re-possession and occupation of the land.

Then it seemed that justice was served and peace would follow when farmers were all smiles.
The land then that led to the conflict is located in Bukangara and Rwehingo in Nyakiyumbu Sub-county, Kasese District.

The Basongora are among the minority ethnic groups in Kasese mainly pastoralists in the low lands of Busongora North and Busongora South.

Clashes erupt
When government gave the land to Basongora pastoralists, who had returned from Virunga National Park in Democratic Republic of Congo where they had gone in search of water and pasture, bloody clashes erupted.

The Bakonzo cultivators protested government’s move to settle the cattle keepers on the 2,050 acres of land and the deployment of police in the area to block whoever wanted to continue cultivating on the disputed land.

The cultivators successfully sued the Attorney General and asked court among others to; order government, its agents and the pastoralists out of their land. Mr Paul Byakatonda, one of the farmers’ leaders, said famine and food scarcity will be no more so long as every farmer repossesses the land they had lost hope in.

Following this, the Basongora community quickly held several meetings and rekindled their old demands of their own district and kingdom. They want to secede from Kasese and from Rwenzururu Kingdom, arguing that their interests are not catered for and are politically marginalised.

Different cultures
The Basongora have gone ahead to crown their own King Rwigi IV Kabumba Rutakirwa Ivan Bwebale amid resistance from different sections in the district. They argue that it is their human right to have a kingdom because they don’t share any cultures with the Bakonzo.

“We have totally different cultures with the Bakonzo, so it is our human right to have our own kingdom” said the Busongora king’s spokesperson, Mr Jacob Muzoora, on Wednesday. Two weeks ago, the Basongora called for the rejection of the Rwenzururu Kingdom anthem in schools in their areas where they stay.

This was after the Basongora elders complained to their cultural leader that their children were being forced to sing the Rwenzururu Kingdom anthem and to dance Bakonzo traditional dance. Bwebale says it is an abomination to see their children dance the Bakonzo traditional dance and sing their kingdom anthem.

“All head teachers in Busongora schools should stand warned that the Basongora have own kingdom meaning that the Rwenzururu culture here is an abuse on us,” Bwebale warned on June 24 at Nyakatonzi Community hall after he announced his cabinet.

Bwebale said the Busongora Kingdom has been in existence though not popular as was established in 1886 by Queen Ikamiro Kogyere. Mr Joseph Baluku, an elder in the Rwenzururu Kingdom, said:

“I am worried of how two kingdoms will operate in one district. Does it mean that Basongora and Bakonzo will have their own separate schools in order not to honour the anthems of the two institutions?”

He added: “I am sensing danger in our district if our leaders don’t decide wisely”. The minority groups say they have been marginalised in the politics and service delivery in Kasese which is led by the majority Bakonzo.

Push for Busongora district on the card
A petition to the district chairperson by Mr Bisanga says the Basongora, Banyabindi and Bachingwe, the three minority groups have been discriminated against, marginalised and oppressed by the district administration on employment, service delivery, politics and education.

The petition calls for the creation of a separate district for entirely the three ethnic groups because the proposed split of Kasese into three administrative units leaves the Basongora, Banyabindi and Bachingwe scattered.

Rwenzururu position
 
However, just three days after Basongora ethnic group crowned their king, the Rwenzururu Kingdom has declared null and void the establishment of Busongora Heritage Kingdom and the coronation of King Rwigi IV Kabumba Rutakirwa Ivan Bwebale.

In a Tuesday press statement signed by the acting prime minister of the Rwenzururu Kingdom, Ms Loice Biira Bwambale, the cabinet resolved not to recognise the Busongora Heritage Kingdom on grounds that they cannot have two kings in one district and kingdom.

“We cannot have a Kingdom within our Kingdom. Obusinga Bwa Rwenzururu does not recognise the so-called King of the Basongora, and therefore declares that his coronation that was conducted last Sunday is Null and Void” the statement reads in part.

The prime minister also directed that the Rwenzururu anthem and flag that were allegedly banned in the area covered by Busongora Kingdom must continue being used as they are recognised symbols of the kingdom.

Ms Bwambale in her statement also warned all ethnic groups in Rwenzururu Kingdom against disrespecting the Omusinga (King), structures and symbols of the monarchy to avoid further provocation.

The Rwenzururu Kingdom cabinet has asked government to come clear on the installation of the Rutakirwa Ivan Bwebale as King of Basongora.

Legal issues
 
Independent legal experts say the Rwenzururu Kingdom has no powers to declare another kingdom null and void reasoning that not every one living on the territory of any kingdom must be a subject to that cultural institution.

“I don’t think a kingdom has any legal backing to declare another cultural institution null and void, not even the High Court can do this” reasoned lawyer Ngaruye Ruhindi, adding, “Not everyone living in Kasese should bow to the Iremangoma (King), not everyone in Kasese is a Mukonzo, however minority they are, other ethnic groups by the Constitution have a right to have their cultural leaders”.

Inside opposition
The family of the late Princess Kogyere of Katwe-Kabatoro town council says they will not recognise the King of the Basongora, claiming that Busongora Kingdom is under the leadership of the Babiito clan.

The Babiito clan mobiliser, Mr Yahaya Kyomya Atwooki, says: “We oppose what happened (coronation) on Sunday because it was done illegally without our consent”.

He adds that the Babiito family has their king in waiting called Bwatali, son to Nyabongo, the late Princess Kogere’s brother and has his regalia at Nyakatonzi Village in Nyakatonzi Sub-county.
====================================
Understanding the origin and the lifestyle of the Basongora
The Basongora, Banyabindi, Bakingwe and Baholu are a minority group in Kasese District.
The Songora or Shongora (plural Basongora, singular Musongora), also known as Hima/Huma/Hema), are a traditionally pastoralist people located in Western Uganda and Eastern Democratic Republic of Congo.

They have distinctive customs and speak ‘Rusongora’ an African language that is originates from Proto-Kordofanian and is similar to Runyankole and Rutooro.

The Basongora population is estimated at about 11,000 in Uganda.
The colonial and neo-colonial governments in Central Africa instituted programmes to encourage the Basongora to abandon their traditional lifestyle, and most of the territory traditionally owned by the Songora community has been appropriated for use as national parks or has been settled and occupied by other communities, notably the Batooro and Bakonzo.

Also Songora territory was partitioned into several districts and is distributed across Uganda and Congo.

The traditional lifestyle of the Basongora is notable for its adaptation to dry savanna and scrublands, as well as mountainous terrain. Cultural tourism should be promoted among the Basongora as an alternative means of income generation, and Basongora should be encouraged to welcome visits to their village to experience their culture, traditions, and lifestyle.

Rwenzururu Kingdom asserts that it cannot have a kingdom within their kingdom.
But Basongora argue that the whole of Kasese District was Busongora County headed by Chief Kogyere under Tooro Kingdom.

Basongora group for Justice and Human rights, is an NGO in Kasese formed about 20 years ago to push for the Basongora rights.
[Wikipedia]
================================
IN SEARCH OF AUTONOMY
The Basongora crowned their own king last Sunday in an attempt to secede from the Rwenzururu Kingdom.

They are also pushing for their own district.
The Busongora Kingdom, if it comes into existence, will cover 20 sub-counties of the present Kasese District.

There are 28 sub-counties including three town councils and three divisions in the district.
According to population reports it is estimated 700, 000 people live in the district.

About the Rwenzururu kingdom
The Rwenzururu region is inhabited by the Konjo and Amba peoples. In the early 20th century, these two tribes were integrated into the Kingdom of Tooro as a political maneuver by the British colonialists.The Bakonjo and Baamba initially accepted being arbitrarily made subjects of the Tooro monarch with resignation, but asked the Uganda Protectorate to provide them their own district in the 1950s, separate from Toro District. The movement declared that they were not part of the Tooro Kingdom on 30 June 1962, three months independence. It was declared an independent Kingdom of Rwenzururu on 30 June 1963 with Isaya Mukirania as king.